Is it just me or are these similar?

168.143.78.183/education/astro/act3/astrology3.html

www.astronomy.ie/astrology.html

if you look closely the answer to the second question on it's first line the ai uses the word fact as opposed to the word datum so how can the possibly be the same .
stephen.

You won't see me touching that one with a barge-pole!

Sure, it seems to be more than a little coincidental, but should it be of any real concern to us here? Does the knowledge that a person MAY (I said friggin' MAY - happy?) have stolen (no dammit that's not the word I wanted to use - better erase that quick!) erm, I mean, may have been inspired by another person's work really have anything to do with IFAS? I don't think so - let him on.

I emailed him last night about the article, pointing out the 'blatant' similarities. His response is:

Yes it is a collection of works by many other authors/researchers that I
have seen or others have given to me over the years, to which I then
added my own spin/conclusions on the matter.

I quite liked Andrew Fraknoi's article when it appeared in Sky & Tel all
those years ago.

The webpage was hastily cobbled together after my talk last year as a
few people wanted some of the biblical references etc so we just threw
the PowerPoint presentation in a html document.

In the talk I *do* credit the original article, but this fact was not on
one of the PowerPoint pages so it got 'lost in translation' so to speak.

The webpage has served its purpose and I think it is better that we take
it offline, which has been done.

Thank you for pointing this out.

If you have an interest in astronomy please subscribe to our FREE
emailing list on our website.

=====
David Moore BSc FRAS, blah blah blah...


Believeable?

The link has indeed been removed from 'his' site.

Seanie.

Believeable?

as much as those prices are good value :roll:

The webpage has served its purpose and I think it is better that we take
it offline, which has been done.

=====
David Moore BSc FRAS, blah blah blah...

Would anyone who saw this article, and has since been deleted, might actually have it saved or retreivable from their visited pages on their web browser? I'd like to get a hold of it to look at it again! :wink:

Seanie.

Would anyone who saw this article, and has since been deleted, might actually have it saved or retreivable from their visited pages on their web browser? I'd like to get a hold of it to look at it again! :wink:

ah Seanie.... Do you really think that the minute Astronomy Ireland gets mentioned someone here would be so suspicious of them to go and make a backup of the evidence?

www.cademuir.net/astronomy.ie/

Cheers,
~Al

ah Seanie.... Do you really think that the minute Astronomy Ireland gets mentioned someone here would be so suspicious of them to go and make a backup of the evidence?

www.cademuir.net/astronomy.ie/

Cheers,
~Al

:twisted: oh how fortune favours the brave!

Thanks Al... I wonder if the Astronomical Society of the Pacific would like to see that, or am I just being too mean? :wink:
It would mean knocking Mr. Moore from his perch a little, especially if he blatantly wants to claim someone elses work as his own... Opinions?

Seanie.

Thanks Al... I wonder if the Astronomical Society of the Pacific would like to see that, or am I just being too mean? :wink:
It would mean knocking Mr. Moore from his perch a little, especially if he blatantly wants to claim someone elses work as his own... Opinions?

Well he has taken it down so I doubt they would care now. But if you do mention it to them please take a copy of the page and dont get my website caught in the middle

Cheers,
~Al

noted Al.